| Please use this identifier to cite or link to this publication: http://hdl.handle.net/10380/3223 |
Automatic Testing Results
by Insight-Journal Dashboard
on Mon Nov 22 09:37:24 2010 for revision #1 



expertise: 5 sensitivity: 3.5 Click here for more details.
Go here to access the main testing dashboard.
Excellent addition!
by David Doria on 2010-10-22 08:13:09 for revision #1 



expertise: 3 sensitivity: 3.5 The authors have implemented a templated, general version of the RANSAC algorithm.
Evidence:The authors demonstrate their classes by performing plane and sphere parameter estimation.
Open Science:The data from which the parameters is estimated is generated by the code. Everything is reproducible.
Reproducibility:I downloaded the code and it compiled on the first try. I ran the planeEstimation executable and it worked as expected.
Use of Open Source Software:No, this is not expected from a submission.
Open source Contributions:Yes, it is very usable. The usage is clearly described as well as demonstrated. To use the code only took seconds, and it only took a few minutes to look through it to get an idea of how to expand it for other estimation tasks.
Code Quality :The code was easy to read. A modern coding style (templates) was used throughout. I have only tested the code on Fedora 13, but I don't see anything obviously non-portable.
Quality of the data :The data is generated by the code.
Interest:The authors mentioned that RANSAC is often used for fundamental matrix operation for camera calibration. This would certainly be an excellent addition!
Resources
| Download Package | |
| Download Paper, View Paper | |
| Download Source code | |
| Github | |
Statistics more
| Global rating: | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
| Review rating: | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() [review]
|
| Code rating: | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
| Paper Quality: |
|
Information more
| Categories: | Hypothesis Testing, Optimization |
| Keywords: | RANSAC, robust estimation, hyperplane, hypersphere, |
| Toolkit: | ITK |
| Export citation: | |
Share
Associated Publications
| RANSAC Plane Fitting for VTK | ||
View license
Send a message to the author




